The ‘three-second food rule’ is a total myth (here’s why)

You must have heard about the ‘three-second rule’ when it comes to dropped food. It’s the idea that if you pick up something you dropped off the floor within three seconds, it’s still safe to eat. But is this rule true? 

In a reel circulating on social media, gastroenterologist Dr Palaniappan Manickam Pal suggests, “If you drop a bar of chocolate on the floor at your home, it’s okay, three seconds later you pick it up and eat it because it’s your home environment. Those microbes are not going to be Thanos (big deal), it could be smaller bad guys but your good gut bacteria will take care of it. But at the same time, you’re giving work to your immune system, you are providing a wide variety of bacteria, it’s all good.”

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by QuantumPodPulse (@quantumpodpulse) 

The same chocolate, he says, if dropped on a hospital floor is dangerous for consumption.  Hospitals can have super strong germs that our bodies might not be able to fight off as easily. “I will not even go near it,” he says.

Consultant dietician and certified diabetes educator Kannika Malhotra says, “There’s no scientific basis to suggest food dropped on the ground magically stays safe within that time frame.”

In fact, she continues, a 2016 study by Rutgers University found that bacteria can contaminate food in less than a second, regardless of the length of contact time. Popular culture has made it seem acceptable, but it’s truly best to discard food if you want to be safe. 

Malhotra explains that the confusion stems from the reality that some surroundings and surfaces are safer than others. “Not to mention, some items may be okay to eat after being dropped,” she agrees. 

How quickly can harmful bacteria and microbes contaminate food?

Malhotra says that contamination can happen shockingly fast – practically instantly! 

Several factors play a role: 

*The type of surface: Porous surfaces like carpets or unsealed wood are like havens for bacteria, increasing the risk of contamination compared to smoother surfaces like glazed tile. 

*Moisture: Wet surfaces facilitate quicker transfer of bacteria than dry ones. Think of a wet countertop versus a dry one. A 2006 study published in the journal Applied and Environmental Microbiology demonstrated this very clearly. 

*Type of food: Foods that are sticky or moist will pick up more bacteria quickly, think of a slice of watermelon versus a potato wafer/cookie. 

Pets can track bacteria from outside. (Source: Freepik)

Specific types of surfaces where the risk of contamination is higher

“Dr Pal makes a great point! Hospital settings are a prime concern due to the types of pathogens that can be present,” Malhotra informs.  

Factors that can affect the safety of surfaces include: 

Frequency of cleaning and disinfection: Regularly disinfected surfaces harbour fewer bacteria. 

Foot traffic: Areas where more people walk introduce more chances of contamination.

Presence of pets: Pets can track bacteria from outside. A 2003 study by researchers at Aston University found that even seemingly clean floors can be surprisingly contaminated.

Potential health risks associated with consuming food that has been dropped on the ground, even for just a few seconds

The risks, even if seemingly small, are very real. They range from mild upset stomach to serious foodborne illnesses caused by bacteria like E. coli or Salmonella. 

“While the ‘3-second rule’ might sometimes seem harmless for healthy adults, it’s a gamble. People with weaker immune systems – including young children, older adults, pregnant women, and the immunocompromised – should always discard dropped food to avoid potential foodborne illness,” Malhotra warns.

Factors that play a huge role as mentioned by her: 

Type of Food: Moist and sticky foods attract more bacteria. 

Cleanliness of surface: Visibly clean doesn’t equal bacteria-free. Even a clean-looking kitchen floor can harbor dangerous microbes. 

Immune system: Those with compromised immune systems – children, the elderly, people with chronic illnesses – are much more vulnerable to even small amounts of harmful bacteria.

If you’re not sure what to do, Malhotra believes that it’s best to err on the side of caution. In other words, if you’re unsure whether it’s okay to eat something that has dropped on the floor, just discard it away. 

Disclaimer: The copyright of this article belongs to the original author. Reposting this article is solely for the purpose of information dissemination and does not constitute any investment advice. If there is any infringement, please contact us immediately. We will make corrections or deletions as necessary. Thank you.